The Ultimate Guide to Choosing the Right Roofing Material for Your Home

Avatar image of Brian Roach Updated on October 23, 2024 by Brian Roach

Table of contents

Selecting the perfect roofing material for your home is a significant decision that impacts your property’s protection, value, and appearance. This comprehensive guide will walk you through the key factors to consider and explain the ins and outs of various roofing options to help you make an informed decision when choosing a roof for your home.

Factors to Consider When Choosing a Roofing Material

Before diving into specific materials, it’s important to understand the elements that should influence your decision:

  1. Climate and weather conditions: Your local weather patterns play a major role in determining the best roofing material for your home.
  2. House architecture and roof pitch: Your home’s style and the roof’s slope can limit your material options.
  3. Local building codes and regulations: Ensure your choice complies with local laws and homeowners’ association rules.
  4. Budget: Consider both initial costs and long-term value when making your decision.
  5. Durability and lifespan: Different materials offer varying levels of longevity and resistance to wear and tear.
  6. Energy efficiency: Some roofing materials can help reduce your energy bills by providing better insulation.
  7. Aesthetics: Your roof significantly affects your home’s curb appeal, so choose a material that complements your property’s style.
  8. Maintenance requirements: Some materials require more upkeep than others, which can impact long-term costs.

Types of Roofing Materials

Choosing the Right Roofing Material banner 1

Let’s explore the most common roofing materials available, diving deeper into their characteristics, applications, and considerations:

Asphalt Shingles

Asphalt shingles remain the most popular roofing material in North America, prized for their affordability and ease of installation. They come in two main types: three-tab shingles and architectural (dimensional) shingles.

Pros:

  • Cost-effective, making them accessible for most homeowners
  • Wide range of colors and styles to match various architectural designs
  • Suitable for many climates, with options for different weather conditions
  • Easy to install and repair, reducing labor costs
  • Good fire resistance, especially with fiberglass-based shingles
  • Architectural shingles offer improved aesthetics and durability

Cons:

  • Shorter lifespan compared to some other materials
  • Less environmentally friendly due to petroleum-based components
  • Can be damaged by extreme weather, such as high winds or hail
  • May develop algae growth in humid climates, though algae-resistant options are available
  • Performance can vary significantly based on quality and installation

Additional Information:

  • Weight: 2-4 pounds per square foot, suitable for most roof structures
  • Energy efficiency: Moderate, with cool roof options available for better reflectivity
  • Maintenance: Regular inspections and occasional cleaning are recommended

Cost range: $70 to $160 per square (100 square feet) Lifespan: 15 to 30 years (architectural shingles typically last longer)

Metal Roofing

Metal roofs have gained popularity for their durability and energy efficiency. Common types include steel, aluminum, copper, and zinc. They come in various forms, such as standing seam, metal shingles, and corrugated panels.

metal roofing

Pros:

  • Extremely durable and long lasting, withstanding severe weather conditions
  • Fire-resistant, potentially lowering insurance premiums
  • Energy-efficient, reflecting solar radiant heat
  • Can be recycled at the end of its lifespan, making it environmentally friendly
  • Low maintenance requirements
  • Lightweight, reducing the structural load on the building
  • Available in a wide range of colors and styles, including options that mimic other materials

Cons:

  • Higher initial cost compared to some other roofing materials
  • Can be noisy during rain or hail, though proper insulation can mitigate this
  • May dent from impacts, particularly softer metals like aluminum
  • Expansion and contraction with temperature changes can cause loosening over time
  • Retrofitting can be challenging due to different installation techniques

Additional Information:

  • Weight: 1-3 pounds per square foot, varying by type
  • Energy efficiency: High, especially with light colors or specialized coatings
  • Maintenance: Periodic inspections for loose fasteners or sealant degradation

Cost range: $120 to $900 per square (varies widely based on metal type and style) Lifespan: 40 to 70 years, with some premium metals lasting even longer

Clay and Concrete Tiles

These tiles offer a distinctive look and exceptional durability, particularly suitable for Mediterranean, Spanish, or southwestern-style homes. Clay tiles are made from natural materials, while concrete tiles are manufactured using cement, sand, and water.

Pros:

  • Very long-lasting, withstanding severe weather conditions
  • Fire-resistant, potentially improving home safety and insurance rates
  • Low maintenance, requiring infrequent repairs or replacements
  • Excellent insulation properties, improving energy efficiency
  • Available in a variety of colors and styles, including options that mimic wood or slate
  • Environmentally friendly, especially clay tiles, which are made from natural materials

Cons:

  • Heavy – typically requiring additional structural support, especially for retrofitting
  • More expensive than some other options, both in materials and installation
  • Can be brittle and break under the impact, such as from falling branches
  • Installation is more complex and time-consuming, requiring specialized skills
  • May be prone to color fading over time, particularly with concrete tiles

Additional Information:

  • Weight: 6-18 pounds per square foot, depending on the type
  • Energy efficiency: High, due to thermal mass and installation air space
  • Maintenance: Periodic inspections for cracked or slipped tiles, and cleaning of drainage channels

Cost range: $300 to $1000 per square Lifespan: 50 to 100 years, with clay generally outlasting concrete

Slate Roofing

Slate is a premium roofing material known for its beauty and longevity. It’s a natural stone product that offers unparalleled durability and a distinctive appearance.

Pros:

  • Extremely durable, withstanding severe weather and temperature fluctuations
  • Fire-resistant, enhancing home safety
  • Resistant to mold, fungus, and rot
  • Environmentally friendly, being a natural product with minimal processing
  • Provides a unique, high-end appearance that can increase property value
  • Available in a variety of colors and sizes for customized looks

Cons:

  • Very heavy – requires specialized structural support, limiting its use in some buildings
  • Expensive, both in terms of material and installation costs
  • Difficult to install and repair, requiring specialized skills and experience
  • Brittle nature can lead to damage from foot traffic during maintenance
  • Limited color options compared to manufactured materials

Additional Information:

  • Weight: 8-15 pounds per square foot, depending on slate thickness
  • Energy efficiency: High due to natural insulating properties
  • Maintenance: Periodic inspections for cracked or loose slates and gutter cleaning to prevent water backup

Cost range: $600 to $1,500 per square Lifespan: 75 to 200 years, with proper installation and maintenance

Wood Shakes and Shingles

Wood roofing offers a natural, rustic look that many homeowners find appealing. Shakes are split from logs and have a rougher appearance, while shingles are sawn and have a smoother, more uniform look.

Wood Shakes and shingles

Pros:

  • A natural and attractive appearance that weathers to a distinctive silver-gray color
  • Good insulation properties, contributing to energy efficiency
  • Can be made from sustainable materials, often using cedar, redwood, or pine
  • Biodegradable at the end of their lifespan
  • Can be repaired by replacing individual shakes or shingles

Cons:

  • Higher maintenance requirements, including regular cleaning and treatments
  • Less fire-resistant, though treatments are available to improve fire rating
  • Vulnerable to insects, rot, and mold, especially in damp climates
  • May be prohibited in some areas due to fire codes
  • Can split, warp, or curl over time, especially in areas with high-temperature fluctuations

Additional Information:

  • Weight: 3-4 pounds per square foot, suitable for most structures
  • Energy efficiency: Good, due to natural insulating properties of wood
  • Maintenance: Regular cleaning, moss removal, and re-oiling or re-staining every few years

Cost range: $250 to $600 per square Lifespan: 20 to 40 years, depending on wood type, climate, and maintenance

Synthetic Roofing Materials

These materials, often made from rubber, plastic, or polymer, are designed to mimic the look of natural materials while offering improved performance. Common types include synthetic slate, composite shingles, and polymer tiles.

Pros:

  • Lightweight, reducing structural requirements and making them suitable for a wide range of buildings
  • Durable, often with good impact resistance and weathering properties
  • Often made from recycled materials, appealing to environmentally-conscious homeowners
  • It can mimic more expensive materials like slate or wood at a fraction of the cost
  • Generally easier to install than the materials they mimic
  • Often come with long warranties due to their durability

Cons:

  • Varying quality between manufacturers, making product selection crucial
  • May not have the same lifespan as traditional materials, especially in harsh climates
  • Some types may absorb water, leading to potential issues in freeze-thaw cycles
  • Relatively new in the market, so long-term performance is still being established
  • May not offer the same authentic look as natural materials upon close inspection

Additional Information:

  • Weight: 1-4 pounds per square foot, varying by product
  • Energy efficiency: Varies by product, with some offering cool roof options
  • Maintenance: Generally low, but may require periodic cleaning and inspections

Cost range: $300 to $650 per square Lifespan: 40 to 50 years, though some premium products claim longer

When choosing a roofing material, consider factors such as local climate, building codes, architectural style, budget, and long-term maintenance requirements. It’s also advisable to consult with a professional roofing contractor to determine the best option for your specific situation.

Maintenance and Care

roof maintenance and care

Regular maintenance can extend the life of your roof. General tips include:

  • Regular inspections (at least annually)
  • Keeping gutters clean
  • Trimming overhanging tree branches
  • Addressing issues promptly

Different materials have specific care instructions. For instance, wood shakes may require periodic treatments, while metal roofs might need to be checked for loose fasteners.

Environmental Considerations

When choosing a roofing material, consider its environmental impact:

  • Energy efficiency: Some materials, like metal and light-colored tiles, can reflect sunlight and reduce cooling costs.
  • Recyclability: Materials like metal and slate can often be recycled at the end of their life.
  • Sustainability: Look for materials made from recycled content or sustainable sources.

Making Your Decision

To choose the right roofing material:

  1. Assess your specific needs and preferences
  2. Research materials that meet those needs
  3. Do your research and trust a local, reputable contractor
  4. Consider both short-term costs and long-term value
  5. Don’t hesitate to ask questions and seek professional advice

Choosing the right roofing material is a significant decision that affects your home’s protection, value, and appearance. By carefully considering factors such as climate, budget, durability, and aesthetics, you can select a roofing material that will serve you well for years to come. Contact Always Be Fair Roofing today and let one of our roofing experts walk you through the process. Remember, a quality roof is an investment in your home’s future.

About the author

Brian Roach

Specializes in insurance repairs at ABF Roofing & Restoration, offering free inspections and top-notch roofing services. With over 20 years of experience in Northeast Ohio, he’s known for honesty, fair pricing, and quality work as a GAF Master Elite Contractor.

The Ultimate Guide to Choosing the Right Roofing Material for Your Home